Stefan is still unsure of Damon’s motivation for making a return to Mystic Falls. Jeremy gets a break from the new history teacher, Alaric Saltzman. He finds his teacher somewhat of an enigma that he is drawn to, and he introduces him to Jenna.

Meanwhile, Bonnie is having nightmares about one of her ancestors, and despite Elena trying to make peace work between the two, Bonnie and Caroline still argue about the medallion. They hold a séance since they are out of ideas on what to do, and when the answer comes to them, they will be surprised even more. Matt comes to Caroline at her time of need, and Damon reveals to Stefan his real reason why he is back at Mystic Falls.